Cooking the Corn Islands

Storm rolling in over the beaches of Big Corn: Corn Islands

Aug, 2016: When people think of Caribbean holiday destinations, the Corn Islands probably aren’t at the top of the list. We fell in love with them though, especially Big Corn. After some less than inspiring visits to the Caribbean, the Corn Islands actually restored my faith in this magical part of the world. From low expectations, we found the lovely laid back locals, the ramshackle but gorgeous coastline and the abundance of fresh, quality seafood to be rather inspiring…especially in the kitchen.

Old school wooden house on Big Corn Island: Corn Islands

Old school wooden house on Big Corn Island


70km off the coast of Nicaragua, this twin set of islands are a little rough around the edges but provide an authentic glimpse into Caribbean culture. Little Corn sees the most tourism and is best equipped with a range of accommodation and restaurant options along with a couple of dive schools. On the other hand, Big Corn is much more local and the commercial hub of the two. Along with some besties from Australia, we initially planned for only a few days but ended up staying1.5 weeks on Big Corn and a few days on it’s little brother.  We did nothing but laze in hammocks, eat amazing food and take the odd dip in the ocean. It was bliss.

Spent of plenty of time with the feet up in the hammock at Yellowtail House: Corn Islands

Spent of plenty of time with the feet up in the hammock at Yellowtail House


Cooking the Corn Islands: Big Corn first impressions

I had only ever really associated the Caribbean with turquoise blue water gently lapping up against coconut fringed, white sandy beaches. Good food wasn’t exactly what came to mind. Still, as we drove around Big Corn during our first day or two this impression started to change. Fishing boats in all shapes and sizes bobbed in the water, 100’s of wooden lobster pots sat piled in front of houses and hand painted signs offered fresh baked coconut bread for sale. Old women swung gently in their rocking chairs while selling fresh pineapples from their verandahs. Every few days an open air butcher would pop up selling freshly killed meat and a dude would do daily laps of the island selling fruit and vegetables from a trailer towed behind his motorbike. The local taxi drivers gave us the inside word on cheap, fresh lobster and I got lucky when a local fisherman walked past with a fresh King Crab in his bag ready to sell. I think it also helped that we were staying in ramshackle little bungalows where when you took a step back from the kitchen bench you were looking straight at that turquoise Caribbean water.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.


Cooking the Corn Islands: Baking whole fish in a sandpit beach oven

At some point my mate Nick and I decided that we wanted to attempt baking a fish in a sand oven on the beach. After a bit of trial and error we worked out the overly convoluted system to purchasing fish from the cooperatives and with a 5kg snapper in hand we set to our mission. We dug a pit just above the waterline about 1m (L) x 0.75m (W) x 0.5m (D) and then built a fire around coconut husks and drift wood. The fish got cleaned in the sea and then rubbed with salt before being stuffed with lemon, ginger, garlic and knobs of butter. Finally we wrapped the whole thing up with multiple layers of banana leaves and tied it with string I made from the fibres of the banana leaf (see below for a few tips on cooking with banana leaves). As the sun went down we lowered our prize into the oven pit, covered it with another layer of banana leaves and sand, and then sat back to wait. With the sound of waves in our ears and a cold beer in our hands, we couldn’t have been more at peace with the Caribbean.

Alas our first attempt at sand baked fish was a bit of a fail with the oven not being nearly hot enough. Unperturbed, we bought some more, smaller fish and made a second run at it a few nights later. This time round, we made our oven a little bigger, lined it with rocks and built a bigger fire with more wood and coconut husks. The rocks proved key to holding in the heat but we were let down by not sourcing enough young banana leaves to wrap our fish with. Despite multiple attempts at wrapping our little fish, the leaves kept breaking apart and in the end we opted for the cheats method of aluminium foil. While slightly disappointed at lacking the authenticity of the banana leaves the aluminium foil was way easier to use. 45 minutes later we opened our roasting hot beach oven and triumphantly pulled out our perfectly cooked little snappers. They were delicate, fragrant and damned delicious.

Second attempt at sand pit oven baked fish worked a treat: Corn Islands

Second attempt at sand pit oven baked fish worked a treat


Cooking the Corn Islands: making Corn Island coconut milk

While we never got to try our sand oven a third time, we did learn how to make our own coconut milk. Coconuts are everywhere on Corn Island and apparently every coconut palm belongs to someone. As a result you can’t just take any old one off the beach. We bought a more mature coconut from Dorsey (you want one with harder flesh) and with a little instruction from our host, set to. The whole process was surprisingly simple. First we grated the coconut flesh and let it soak for two hours in a mixture of the coconut water and fresh water. Then we just strained the whole mixture and squeezed out the remaining coconut milk with our hands. In just over 2.5 hours we had made coconut milk which then found it’s way into a delicious Beef Rendang.

Grating a mature coconut to make coconut milk: Corn Islands

Grating a mature coconut to make coconut milk


Cooking the Corn Islands: other tasty treats

And so the Corn Island culinary adventures continued. The aforementioned King Crab got steamed and folded into a luxurious crab omelette for breakfast while a few kilo’s of fresh lobster went into a rich tomato and chili penne. We went to the next door restaurant for a bowl of the slightly stodgy local speciality Rondon (sometimes ‘run-down’ pronounced not as good as we hoped) and then there was the coconut bread…Fresh coconut bread made well is something like brioche. It’s soft, every so slightly sweet and goes amazingly well as french toast. We tried a few different french toast combos. Definitely the highlight was slabs of eggy coconut bread topped with fresh mango cheeks, tangy natural yoghurt and a drizzle of some wild Amazonian honey we had bought in the jungle a few hours outside of Manaus. So good!

Fresh lobster ready for the pot: Corn Islands

Fresh lobster ready for the pot


Coconut bread french toast with fresh mango, natural yoghurt and wild Amazonian honey: Corn Islands

Coconut bread french toast with fresh mango, natural yoghurt and wild Amazonian honey


The Corn Islands aren’t exactly the easiest places to get to and there are definitely places with more beautiful beaches. However, if you’re looking for an authentic Caribbean experience and are willing to dive into some of the local produce then you will be rewarded with an amazing time.

Cooking the Corn Islands: travel and feasting tips

  • Cooking with banana leaves:
    • First off, cooking with banana leaves isn’t as easy as expected as they’re quite fragile and often split when you’re wrapping them around what ever you’re trying to cook
    • As a result have more banana leaves on hand than what you actually need to account for the ones you’re going to lose
    • If using straight off the tree, try and get the big young leaves (versus older ones which have already split) and wash them well with the spine still in. Once washed, cut them into the size that you want and wrap them carefully around your fish.
    • If at home buying them frozen from the super market should make it a little easier as it would appear that freezing them first makes them more pliable versus brittle
  • There are two ways of getting to the Corn Islands, by boat or plane. We tried and both and while more costly we would definitely recommend spending the money and flying. Stay tuned for our blog Getting to the Corn Islands: to sail or not to sail for more information.
  • Shuttle boats run between Big and Little Corn a few times a day, take 30mins each way and cost USD5/person. Try and choose a smooth day as they are only little boats.
  • On Big Corn we stayed at Yellowtail House on Sally Peachie beach. The friendly local owner Dorsey has two simple but perfectly functional beach bungalows. At USD25/night they are a real bargain considering they have uninterrupted water views. Dorsey doesn’t have a website or email but can be reached by phone on +505 8909 8050.
  • One minor problem with Big Corn is the lack of wifi. Seva’s restaurant next to Dorsey’s has patchy wifi (at best). Casa Canada on the south east side of the island probably had the best wifi we could find but even that wasn’t great.

You Might Also Like


  • Reply
    Kavey at Kavey Eats
    April 1, 2017 at 8:25 am

    Love love love this post! Love that you stayed in a house where you cooked yourselves, love that you really got into the vibe of buying from the many local vendors, and particularly love your experiments with making a sand oven not once but twice. For me, food is a hugely important aspect to travelling, so your post has really been rather inspiring!

    • Reply
      April 1, 2017 at 7:50 pm

      Thanks so much Kavey. We don’t always get to cook much when on the road but every now and then we stop somewhere and really get stuck in. Big Corn was a perfect spot as there was so much amazing seafood and nothing really else to do but eat! So glad you liked the post!

  • Reply
    Megan Jerrard
    April 1, 2017 at 8:53 am

    Really interesting! You’re right, I don’t really associate the Caribbean and the small islands throughout as a foodie destination in their own right, but the Corn Islands sound like they have a pretty unique and incredible culinary scene. Cooking in a sand oven sounds like quite the adventure, good work finally getting it going! And quite amazing to learn that every coconut palm belongs to someone on the island – not something I would have assumed!

    • Reply
      April 1, 2017 at 7:53 pm

      Thanks a bunch Megan! Cooking in a sand oven was awesome. Definitely want to try it again. Learnt an awesome goat recipe in Mexico which involves an earth oven will try the same kind of technique. The Corn Islands are totally worth the effort!

  • Reply
    Sandy N Vyjay
    April 1, 2017 at 11:54 am

    The Corn Islands seem so full of the Caribbean spirit and so close to its culture. I was fascinated by how you made the coconut milk. I will try it out at home, of course minus the fresh caribbean coconuts. It would be the coconuts got from the nearby supermarket. 🙂

    • Reply
      April 1, 2017 at 7:55 pm

      Thanks so much Sandy. We’ll be publishing a more detailed recipe for making coconut milk in the next few days. Making it fresh was awesome.

  • Reply
    Jenn and Ed Coleman
    April 2, 2017 at 4:32 am

    I have heard great things about Nicaragua. I could imagine cooking fresh fish on the beach under a full moon with my mates. That would be outstanding.

    • Reply
      April 4, 2017 at 7:27 am

      Nicaragua is great and I reckon the next ‘it’ destination in Central America. It has all the natural beauty and is still relatively untouched by mass tourism (except for a few spots). We definitely couldn’t recommend the Corn Islands highly enough!

  • Reply
    April 2, 2017 at 8:16 am

    The corn islands look like secluded untouched islands. I would love to go there and try to cook on banana leaves. Sounds like a real adventure!

    • Reply
      April 4, 2017 at 7:30 am

      They’re certainly secluded. We reckon that tourism hasn’t completely taken off there (yet) because it is a bit of a mission to get to and it’s still a little rough around the edges. These are also the reasons why we loved them so much (among others)!

  • Reply
    Mel and Marcus
    April 2, 2017 at 11:42 am

    Great post, we were totally unfamiliar with the Corn Islands. The food looks really fresh and tasty although we are not big fans of cooking it ourselves.

    • Reply
      April 4, 2017 at 7:31 am

      Thanks so much. Glad you enjoyed it! IF you’re ever in the region then we would definitely recommend a cheeky stopover for a week or two!

  • Reply
    carla abanes
    April 3, 2017 at 12:01 am

    I use banana leaves all the time when we go camping. To soften the leaves so that it rolls with the food that you’re wrapping them in, pass the banana leaves over a fire for a split second, just a hint of change of the green color and its done. That way its soft and will follow your hands and your food.

    • Reply
      April 4, 2017 at 7:26 am

      That is genius, thanks for the tip. Splitting banana leaves are exactly what thwarted our second attempt at the sand oven. Will have to try this next time. What do you do if at home (assuming you don’t have an open fire in your house :))!

  • Reply
    Vicki Louise
    April 3, 2017 at 1:25 pm

    I had never heard of the Corn Islands before your post! They seem so full of Caribbean charm, I’d love to visit one day! (Here and the rest of the Caribbean! lol)

    • Reply
      April 4, 2017 at 7:24 am

      You really must visit! At first we weren’t overly impressed with the Caribbean but the Corn Islands absolutely restored the faith.

  • Reply
    Reshma Narasing
    April 4, 2017 at 4:09 am

    Interesting to see the Corn Islands have so many things to offer. Great to see that you not only cooked (sand oven!) but experimented a lot in that! It’s hard to cook while traveling when all you need is some ready food, but loved that you enjoyed!

    • Reply
      April 4, 2017 at 7:23 am

      The Corn Islands (and especially Big Corn) were a total unexpected gem. We loved them!

  • Reply
    April 5, 2017 at 9:25 pm

    The Caribbean is one of my favorites areas of the world. But you’re right, I had never really heard of the Corn Islands until the last few years when a lot of travel bloggers seem to be going to them. I didn’t even realize they were considered part of the Caribbean. Aside from the cooking – which looks delicious – what activities are there to do on Big Corn?

    • Reply
      April 6, 2017 at 6:53 am

      Thanks Jennifer! We did a lot of very little on the Corn’s. Daily routine was usually cook breakfast, read / write in diary / lie in hammock / head to the fish cooperative / market, cook lunch, read / write in diary / lie in hammock / walk on beach / swim….sense a pattern? We considered doing some scuba diving on Little Corn as heard there is some amazing diving to be had but then reverted to aforementioned activities. Outside of the above there isn’t really much to do on the Corn Islands. That’s what we loved about it!

  • Reply
    best financial planning tools
    April 10, 2017 at 2:04 am

    Oh my goodness! Incredible article dude! Thank you, However I am having issues with your RSS. I don’t know the reason why I cannot subscribe to it. Is there anybody else having similar RSS problems? Anybody who knows the answer will you kindly respond? Thanks!!

    • Reply
      April 24, 2017 at 4:18 pm

      Hi there, am not sure why you weren’t able to subscribe. I haven’t heard of anyone else having issues. Are you still having the same problem?

  • Reply
    financial planner
    April 11, 2017 at 6:00 pm

    I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you design this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz respond as I’m looking to design my own blog and would like to know where u got this from. kudos

    • Reply
      April 24, 2017 at 4:17 pm

      Hi there, thanks so much. Really glad you like it. Actually I did it all myself after a bunch of looking at other sites and talking to other bloggers. What kind of site are you looking to develop?

    Leave a Reply